Corbyn and Smith fail to land blows on disability

Corbyn and Smith fail to land blows on disability

The contest for leadership of the Labour party is gathering both heat and momentum. What it lacks for disabled people, says Ian Macrae, is relevance and inclusivity.

In the red corner with a reputation for doggedly going forward in the face of fierce opposition, for tenaciously hanging in there and for soaking up whatever the opposition has to throw at him, is Jeremy Corbyn.

Also laying claim to the red corner, Owen Smith has acquired a name for being a ducker and diver: he claims to be strong with the left and the right, is fast on his feet and desperate to deliver the knock-out punch.

But neither Corbyn nor Smith has yet delivered for disabled people watching from the sidelines.

Corbyn began round one promisingly setting out his “Five ills of the 21st century”. These were discrimination, particularly in the workplace, inequality, neglect, insecurity and prejudice.

There cannot be many disabled people in Britain who have not experienced at least one of these negative aspects of life. There will be very many who have fallen victim to them all.

And yet there’s been no mention of disabled people or the barriers and attitudes we face in respect of these five ills by Corbyn.

Which seems neglectful on his part and ungrateful given that two letters signed by a variety of organisations and individuals recently appeared in the press claiming that “millions of disabled people” were longing for a Corbyn victory.

The austerity against which Corbyn rails is well-known to have hit disabled people as hard as many and harder than most. Erosion of social security benefits, a fixation on the return to work agenda and the broken machinery which has so badly failed to hold it up, not to mention the constant harping on about “scroungers” and the “something for nothing society”. These are the things which have characterised the Cameron/Osborne axis’s approach to disabled people.

So far there has been not a word from Corbyn on what Labour would do to begin to correct and redress these imbalances.

Meanwhile, Smith has come crashing in with a welter of policy proposals: the re-introduction of the 50p tax rate; a wealth tax aimed at those earning over £150,000 a year; measures to improve workplace security and equality; not to mention a promise to “smash Theresa May back on her heels”.

But he is also so far silent on whether he’d repeal regressive and anti-inclusive legislation, rebuild a social security system which actually meets people’s needs and set out initiatives which would create genuine opportunities to enable those who can get into work.

So at present it looks as though disabled people have fallen between these two combatants’ stools. We can only hope that a willingness to join the fight for disabled people to get our lives back will be more in evidence in coming rounds.

Seconds out! Round two.

4 thoughts on “Corbyn and Smith fail to land blows on disability

  1. Ian I am with you on all you information an disabled people are being treated terrible my son who is born with his disability though no fault of his but though doctors . I as a carer gets treated badly too do disabled in my son’s words are they are all treated as scroungers thank you for you words on here Elizabeth Brown


  2. A little misleading Ian as any disabled activist over the last few years will have known how well Corbyn & McDonnell have supported disability rights even against their own party. In fact they have a better record on disability rights than the only recently formed ‘Disability Labour’. There simply isn’t a parity between Smith and Corbyn on this especially when you know Smith threatened a disabled woman with a lawyer if she repeated that he had said Labour would not oppose the WCA as it would not ply well in the right wing tabloids. An opposition which Smith refused to support yet both Corbyn and McDonnell have opposed it since day one. The reason grassroots disabled organisation have supported Corbyn is because he has supported them for years, not to get headlines or to advance his career, but because it is the right thing to do when you believe in human rights. Corbyn has a strong record on supporting disabled people, Smith has none. So this is really a rather misleading comparison.


  3. My impression is the activist absence of organizations of and for persons with disabilities as recommended by DPI and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
    Kindly apply the UNCRPWD principals and objectives in pursuit of Equal opportunities for persons with disabilities.
    Kindly note, your government is obliged in applications of the UNCRPWD as a member state of the UN.
    Thanking you in anticipation of a favorable response.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s